Breaking News
More () »

Phoenix's Leading Local News: Weather, Traffic, Sports and more | Phoenix, Arizona | 12NEWS.com

Activists say Phoenix police union contract provides minimal transparency

The proposed contract between the City of Phoenix and Phoenix Law Enforcement Association will go before the city council on Wednesday.

PHOENIX — UPDATE: Phoenix city council voted Wednesday to approve the contract with the Phoenix Law Enforcement Association.


The City of Phoenix says a new proposed contract between the city and the Phoenix Law Enforcement Association is focused on accountability and transparency.

The proposed contract is up for public comment and approval at the city council meeting on Wednesday.

However, activists say the terms reached do not go far enough.

Contract includes raises, adds new policies, strips away current ones

Highlights of the more than 100-page contract include:

  • A 0.5% raise because officers agree to the new accountability measures. In addition to other raise terms.
  • The Chief being able to fire officers immediately if they commit a job-related felony. This would eliminate a waiting period that’s currently in place.
  • Witness officers will not be able to meet with the union before being interviewed by investigators
  • Some past discipline measures won’t be able to be removed from officers’ files.

Lori Bays, Chief Human Resources Officer for the City of Phoenix said the city was focused on accountability and transparency in their contract negotiations with PLEA.

“I believe we’ve addressed some of the community concerns we’ve heard,” Bays said.

RELATED: New Phoenix police union contract touts greater accountability, amid scandal over police handling of protests

Activists say the contract doesn’t go far enough

Viri Hernandez, director of Poder in Action, a community advocacy group said she’d like to see councilmembers reject the proposed contract.

“This contract does not go far enough. There’s really nothing changed in furthering accountability,” Hernandez said.

Hernandez adds she believes the terms outlined are providing minimal transparency.

“The city is trying to give them a 0.5% raise for that? That is millions of dollars for something that should be just common sense,” Hernandez said.

Former Phoenix assistant police chief says terms are a big step forward 

Kevin Robinson, who now teachers at Arizona State University, spent decades in law enforcement at the Phoenix Police Department, including more than a decade as an assistant chief.

Robinson said he was involved in three union contract negotiations during his time.

“I think it’s one of the most progressive contracts I’ve seen in a  very long time,” Robinson said.

Robinson says policies like witness officers not being able to meet with the union before being interviewed by investigators and some discipline matters staying in an officer’s file are particularly progressive terms.

“The Phoenix Police Department is making some significant strides in wrestling back the management rights that the police chief can exercise that he, or in this case – she, sees fit,” Robinson said.

“I think it’s critical to having a police department that is forward moving, that is inclusive, that is transparent, that is one with the community,” Robinson said.

Phoenix City Council to vote on the contract Wednesday 

The Phoenix City Council will hear public comment on the proposed contract on Wednesday at its regularly scheduled meeting at 2:30 p.m. The council is set to vote on the contract as well.

Arizona Politics

Track all of our current updates with Arizona politics on our 12 News YouTube channel. Subscribe for updates on all of our new uploads.