Breaking News
More () »

$5 million Phoenix settlement is 'first step' in achieving justice, Muhammad Muhaymin's family says

Muhaymin's family says the $5 million settlement is an opportunity for change. Their attorney plans to cooperate with the DOJ's investigation into the Phoenix PD.

PHOENIX — On Wednesday, Phoenix City Council voted 7-2 in favor of approving a $5 million settlement agreement with the family of Muhammad Muhaymin Jr., ending a nearly five-year-long legal battle.

Muhaymin died in Phoenix police custody in 2017 while face down, handcuffed and telling officers “I can’t breathe.”  

RELATED: 'There was no reason to treat him in that manner': Phoenix City Council votes to approve $5 million settlement from 2017 in-custody death

The settlement is the "first step in achieving justice," Muhammad's sister, Mussallina Muyahmin said. 

Mussallina's first ask is for the police officers involved in Muhammad's death to be held accountable, she said.

"Agreeing to the settlement sends the message that it wasn't okay what happened to Muhammad," Mussallina said. 

She said she hopes the settlement will spark change in the police department. Change that could come as the Department of Justice continues its "pattern or practice" investigation into the Phoenix PD. 

RELATED: 5 things the feds are investigating in the Phoenix police department

Attorney David Chami represents Muhaymin's family and said that the Justice Department had already reached out to the family in regards to their investigation

Chami is looking forward to speaking with the DOJ in the near future, he said. 

"The DOJ's investigation involves a couple of components that were central to our case, and that's dealing with the homeless population, and the police's dealing with people with mental health issues," Chami said. "And those two populations intersect each other."

About 20 percent of the homeless population in America suffers from severe mental illness, compared to the five percent of Americans who suffer from severe mental illness, according to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and the National Institute of Mental Health. 

The DOJ is investigating allegations of excessive force and abuse within the Phoenix Police Department; specifically the police response to homeless people and the city's response to people with disabilities. 

RELATED: Phoenix Police Chief joining national police reform group

Chami said that Muhammad's death was not in vain.

"It did spark a conversation and it will change his children's lives," Chami said.

Muhaymin left behind two children who Chami says are great and argued it's a testament to the type of father he was.

For Muhaymin's family, it's difficult to keep reliving what happened, and Wednesday's settlement - and the hope for change - gives them an opportunity to start healing the wound from this tragedy.

"I have children, I have grandchildren. We want them to live in a world that recognized their humanity," Mussallina said.


Learn more about other 12 News investigations by subscribing to the 12 News YouTube channel and watching our I-Team playlist. 

RELATED: 'We’re not afraid of transparency': Phoenix Police Chief Jeri Williams discusses reform in department